Performance Assessment of FO-PID Temperature Control System Using a Fractional Order LQG Benchmark

In this paper, a fractional order LQG benchmark is proposed for the control performance assessment of fractional order control systems. Similar to the conventional LQG benchmark, the fractional order LQG performance benchmark curve is determined by the numerical calculation method, which avoids the calculation of the complex interaction matrix. The fractional order process model is discretized via fractional order calculus. Meanwhile, the fractional order integral is introduced into the conventional LQG cost function. Then solving the linear quadratic Gaussian problem under the fractional order model and fractional control, the optimal input and output variances are determined for different weighting factors and the performance curves can be achieved. The comparison between fractional order LQG and the conventional LQG shows the improvement of the proposed benchmark under the same condition. The proposed benchmark can provide a more direct and superior reference standard to evaluate the performance of fractional order control system. Finally, a case study of fractional order PID(FO-PID) controller in industrial heating furnace temperature control experiment with model matching and model mismatch conditions is used to verify the effectiveness of the proposed benchmark.