Comparison of Linear and Rotary Electric Machine Topologies for a Hybrid Hydraulic Electric Architecture of Off-Highway Vehicles

Electrification of off-highway vehicles offers the benefits of improved energy efficiency, enhanced controllability, and reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. However, progress towards electrification has been limited by the low power density of electric components compared to hydraulic components. A recently proposed hybrid hydraulic electric vehicle architecture provides a potential solution to these power density challenges by minimizing the required power rating of the electric components. This paper investigates the optimal design of linear and rotary electric machines for this new system architecture. Key performance metrics are identified for the electric machine, several variants of electric machines are analytically sized and compared for two different power levels, and an FEA-assisted design optimization is performed on promising candidates. Based on the optimization results, it is shown that an axial flux rotary machine is most suitable for implements requiring high power ratings, while the linear machines form factor makes it a compelling candidate for lower power implements.