Generalized Necessary and Sufficient Robust Boundedness Results for Feedback Systems

Classical sufficient conditions for ensuring the robust stability of a dynamical system in feedback with a nonlinearity include passivity, small gain, circle, and conicity theorems. In this article, we present a generalized version of these results for arbitrary semi-inner product spaces. Our result is purely algebraic, and holds even when the conventional discrete or continuous-time causal dynamical systems are replaced by general nonlinear relations, where there need not exist a notion of time. Our result clarifies when the sufficient conditions for robust stability are also necessary, and explains why stronger assumptions, such as linearity and time-invariance are typically needed to prove necessity in the conventional dynamical systems setting.