Performance Comparison of Fault-Tolerant Control for Triple Redundant 3 × 3-Phase Motors Driven by Mono-Inverter

In this article, the fault-tolerant control (FTC) strategy based on current redistribution is compared for three types of triple redundant
$3\times 3$
-phase motor: surface-mounted permanent magnet synchronous motor (SPMSM), synchronous reluctance motor (SynRM), and permanent magnet-assisted synchronous reluctance motor (PMa-SynRM), under a single-phase open-circuit fault. The output torque of SPMSM and SynRM is produced by permanent magnet (PM) torque and reluctance torque, respectively. Nevertheless, for PMa-SynRM, it is necessary to determine the distribution ratio of PM torque and reluctance torque in the proposed FTC strategy. By comparing the FTC performance of motors, the conclusions are as follows: 1) torque ripple of the SPMSM can be completely suppressed; 2) torque ripple minimization for the SynRM and PMa-SynRM can be realized; and 3) optimal solution obtained in SynRM can also be applied to the PMa-SynRM when the load is heavy. In addition, to reduce the complexity and improve the reliability of the control system, a mono-inverter-driven triple-paralleled control system is constructed in healthy and postfault operations. The comparison results of the FTC strategy for three types of motor are obtained by simulation. And the experimental results based on a
$3\,\times \,3$
-phase PMa-SynRM are accomplished to verify the feasibility of the theory.