Comparison of Rational Krylov and Vector Fitting in Transient Simulation of Transmission Lines and Cables

This paper presents stringent comparisons between Vector Fitting (VFIT), Relaxed Vector Fitting (R-VFIT) and Rational Krylov Fitting (RKFIT) techniques in the fitting of transmission line and cable functions to rational forms while accounting for the frequency dependence of electrical parameters. The fitting procedures encapsulate new solution strategies to improve fitting performance. Various case studies are presented to assess the performance of RKFIT in terms of model order reduction, passivity violation and computing times. In addition, the use of RKFIT in obtaining the frequency dependent cable model (FDCM) is demonstrated for the first time together with a resolved case study that showed unstable behavior with the universal line model (ULM) methodology.