Performance Comparison of Typical Frequency Response Strategies for Power Systems With High Penetration of Renewable Energy Sources

Droop control, inertia control, and PD control are three typical frequency response (FR) strategies of grid-tied inverters interfaced renewable energy sources (RES) to restrain the power system frequency indicators, i.e., frequency deviation (
$\Delta \omega $
) and the rate of change of frequency (RoCoF). Due to the highly limited inverter capacity, the FR performance in power systems with high RES penetration should be optimized. To this end, this paper first analyzes the impact of high-penetration renewable energy injection on power system frequency stability, and derives the system frequency expressions in the absence of an FR scheme, and in the presence of droop/inertia/PD controls that are representative for various virtual synchronous generator-based FR schemes. Under the same constraint of available FR capacity, control parameter ranges of these FR schemes are obtained, and their optimal conditions for restraining the maxima of
$\Delta \omega $
and RoCoF are identified and compared analytically. Comparison conclusions are finally proved by the provided experiment and simulation results.