Innovative Low-Cost Sub-Fractional HP BLDC Claw-Pole Machine Design for Fan Applications

As for mass-produced sub-fractional horsepower drives, non-optimal motor behavior (e.g., high cogging torque, output torque ripple, and noise) is often accepted when cost can be reduced, provided reliability is not compromised. This paper proposes an innovative claw-pole motor design for a low-cost single-phase brushless direct current fan drive, improving motor behavior with no increase to the manufacturing cost: 1) reducing cogging torque by proposing unconventional claw-pole skewing and 2) ensuring self-starting capability by implementing air-gap asymmetry. Both measures help reduce the total output torque ripple. The goal is to reduce fan drive noise, especially at low-speed operation, where cogging torque is often the dominating noise source. The design of stator claw skewing and air-gap asymmetry is presented; their effects on motor quantities are studied via simulations and experiments. With the exception of a small reduction of about 1.8% in the back electromotive force fundamental, skewing the stator claws by 30° can reduce the cogging torque by 23% in the simulations and by 28% in the experiments.