Improving the Performance of Backward Chained Behavior Trees that use Reinforcement Learning

In this paper we show how to improve the performance of backward chained behavior trees (BTs) that include policies trained with reinforcement learning (RL). BTs represent a hierarchical and modular way of combining control policies into higher level control policies. Backward chaining is a design principle for the construction of BTs that combines reactivity with goal directed actions in a structured way. The backward chained structure has also enabled convergence proofs for BTs, identifying a set of local conditions to be satisfied for the convergence of all trajectories to a set of desired goal states. The key idea of this paper is to improve performance of backward chained BTs by using the conditions identified in a theoretical convergence proof to configure the RL problems for individual controllers. Specifically, previous analysis identified so-called active constraint conditions (ACCs), that should not be violated in order to avoid having to return to work on previously achieved subgoals. We propose a way to set up the RL problems, such that they do not only achieve each immediate subgoal, but also avoid violating the identified ACCs. The resulting performance improvement depends on how often ACC violations occurred before the change, and how much effort, in terms of execution time, was needed to re-achieve them. The proposed approach is illustrated in a dynamic simulation environment.